Article

Difference Between E2 Visa and EB5 Visa

visa-application-composition-with-europe-america-flag

The E2 and EB5 visas provide specialized routes for each foreign national looking to invest in the U.S., catering to diverse investment objectives. The E 2 visa, designed for individuals from treaty nations, demands a significant investment in a U.S. enterprise and offers a temporary nonimmigrant visa status, enabling investors to oversee their operations without granting permanent residency. Conversely, the EB 5 visa, frequently referred to as the investment green card, requires a greater investment in ventures that satisfy particular job creation criteria, providing a direct route to permanent residency.

This blog will explore these differences in detail, emphasizing the importance of understanding the investment amount, visa status, and potential for permanent residency to aid investors in making informed decisions. Consulting with an experienced immigration lawyer is advised to navigate the complex immigration process.

What is an E2 Visa?

The E2 visa, a nonimmigrant visa, is specifically designed for nationals from treaty countries who make a substantial investment in a U.S. business enterprise. As a key vehicle for foreign investment, the E2 Visa USA allows principal investors to enter and work in the United States based on the investment amount they control, without leading to permanent residency.

This visa requires that the investment must be substantial and sufficient to ensure the successful operation of the enterprise. The investor must also have a significant degree of control over the business. Unlike the EB5 visa, the E2 does not have a set minimum investment amount but the funds must be substantial relative to the total cost of either purchasing an established enterprise or creating a new one. Additionally, the business must not merely be marginal but must have the present or future capacity to generate more than enough income to provide a minimal living for the investor and their family.

Key requirements for the E2 visa include proving that the investment funds come from a legitimate source and that the investor is able to develop and direct the business. This visa type is ideal for investors who wish to actively manage their investments without the intent of obtaining permanent resident status in the U.S.

What is an EB5 Visa?

The EB5 visa, officially recognized as an immigrant visa, serves as a gateway for foreign nationals seeking permanent residency in the United States through substantial investment. The purpose of the EB5 application is to stimulate the U.S. economy through job creation and capital investment by foreign investors.

This investment visa requires foreign investors to invest a minimum set amount—typically $1,050,000 or $800,000 if investing in a high unemployment or rural area, known as a Targeted Employment Area (TEA). The investment must lead to the creation of at least 10 full-time jobs for U.S. workers within a specified period. The principal investor has the option to invest directly in a new or existing commercial enterprise or through a regional center, which can handle the investment and job creation aspects on behalf of the investor.

An EB5 visa grants conditional permanent residency to the investor, their spouse, and unmarried children under the age of 21. After meeting the job creation and investment criteria for a certain period, investors can apply to remove the conditions on their residency, securing a permanent green card.

For more detailed guidance and to ensure compliance with the complex regulations of the EB5 program, potential investors are encouraged to consult with an EB5 visa attorney, who can provide essential insights and assist in navigating the immigration process. This visa not only facilitates significant foreign investment into the U.S. but also offers a direct path to American citizenship for eligible investors and their families.

Differences Between E2 and EB5 Visas

  1. Immigrant vs. Nonimmigrant Status

    The E2 visa is a nonimmigrant visa, allowing treaty country nationals temporary residency to manage their investments, while the EB5 visa is an immigrant visa granting eligible investors a path to permanent residency and a green card.

  2. Source of Funds

    Both visas require proof of legally obtained investment funds, but the EB5 visa additionally demands detailed documentation to trace the path of the funds, including their lawful source.

  3. Ownership of Business

    E2 visa holders must substantially control the business, whereas EB5 investors may own parts of a larger project, especially if investing through a regional center.

  4. Minimum Investment Amount

    The E2 visa does not have a specified minimum investment amount but requires a substantial amount relative to the business. In contrast, the EB5 visa mandates a minimum investment of either $800,000 or $1,050,000, depending on the location of the business.

  5. Place of Filing

    E2 visas are generally processed at U.S. consulates abroad, while EB5 applications may be filed domestically if the applicant is adjusting status or at a consulate for initial entry.

  6. Nationality Requirement

    E2 visas are available only to nationals from countries with a qualifying treaty with the United States; there are no nationality restrictions for the EB5 visa.

  7. Timeline for Processing

    Processing times for E2 visas are typically shorter, ranging from a few weeks to a few months, whereas EB5 visa processing can take several years, especially if a visa backlog exists.

  8. Job Creation Requirement

    EB5 visas require the creation of at least 10 full-time jobs for U.S. workers. The E2 visa does not have a direct job creation requirement but expects the business to be sizable enough to have a significant economic impact.

  9. Work Authorization

    Both visas provide work authorization for the investor; however, E2 dependents can also work in the U.S., whereas EB5 dependents must apply separately for work authorization.

  10. Taxation

    E2 visa holders are taxed on worldwide income if they meet the substantial presence test, similar to EB5 holders who are considered permanent residents for tax purposes.

  11. Time Spent in the U.S.

    E2 visa holders must maintain intent to leave upon visa expiration or termination of status, whereas EB5 visa holders can seek to stay indefinitely as permanent residents.

  12. Freedom to Pursue Other Opportunities

    E2 visa holders must focus on the enterprise that qualified them for the visa. In contrast, EB5 visa holders have more flexibility to engage in various business ventures after fulfilling initial investment and job creation requirements.

This comparison highlights the functional distinctions between the E2 and EB5 visas, showcasing the unique advantages and considerations for foreign investors considering U.S. immigration pathways. Consulting with an experienced immigration lawyer is recommended to navigate the specific requirements and optimize the immigration process.

Comparison Table: E2 Visa VS EB5 Visa

Comparison Table: E2 vs. EB5 Visas

This table provides a succinct overview of the key differences between the E2 and EB5 visas, ideal for potential investors comparing these options for U.S. immigration and investment.

Benefits of an Investment Green Card (EB5)

Obtaining an EB5 visa offers numerous long-term advantages, prominently providing a pathway to permanent residency and U.S. citizenship, which are considerable benefits not afforded by nonimmigrant visas like the E2. This investment green card requires a substantial investment—typically $800,000 in a Targeted Employment Area (TEA) or $1,050,000 in other areas—into a U.S. commercial enterprise.

Key benefits include:

  • Permanent Residency Status: EB5 investors, along with their spouses and unmarried children under 21, can attain conditional permanent residency that can transition to a permanent green card after fulfilling certain conditions, such as job creation requirements. This status allows for easier access to education, more employment opportunities, and eligibility for various social benefits.

  • Direct Path to Citizenship: After maintaining permanent resident status for five years, EB5 visa holders can apply for U.S. citizenship, offering security and the full rights of an American citizen, including the ability to vote.

  • Freedom to Live Anywhere: Unlike some other visas that may require the holder to live near their investment or business, EB5 investors have the freedom to reside anywhere in the United States, from major metropolitan areas to quieter rural settings, regardless of where their investment enterprise is located.

  • No Sponsor Required: The EB5 visa does not require a U.S. employer or family member to sponsor the visa, giving foreign investors control over their immigration process.

  • Job Creation Flexibility: Investors can create jobs directly through their own enterprise or indirectly via a regional center, providing flexibility in how they meet the job creation requirement, which is pivotal for satisfying visa conditions.

For those considering this pathway, consulting with experienced E2 Visa lawyers can offer crucial guidance through the complex immigration process, ensuring that all investment funds are appropriately managed and the immigration services’ criteria are met. This expert advice is vital, especially when navigating potential issues like visa processing delays or meeting the specific minimum investment requirements effectively.

Conclusion

Choosing between the E2 and EB5 visas depends on individual goals, investment capabilities, and long-term aspirations. The E2 visa, ideal for investors from treaty countries seeking a temporary stay without a direct path to permanent residency, requires a substantial investment but less than the EB5. It suits those looking to actively manage a business venture without necessarily aiming for a green card. On the other hand, the EB5 visa is designed for foreign nationals looking to secure permanent residency through a larger financial commitment and the creation of jobs, fulfilling the substantial investment criteria set in either standard or targeted employment areas.

Both visas serve as crucial tools for economic growth, attracting foreign investment and creating jobs in the U.S. Understanding the nuances of each—such as minimum investment amounts, visa status, job creation requirements, and eligibility for permanent residency—is essential. For detailed guidance tailored to specific circumstances, consulting with a US immigration lawyer for Singaporeans can provide strategic insights to navigate the complex immigration process, ensuring compliance with all regulatory requirements and maximizing the likelihood of a successful application.

Jeremy Abernathy

9 January 2024

I had the pleasure of working with Verdie and Nessa to obtain my E2 Visa. Their in-depth knowledge and experience allowed me to be fully prepared in my application and they were able to answer all questions leading up to the Visa interview.

Saeed Muhammad

15 December 2023

Verdie was an amazing attorney, providing exceptional client care throughout the process. He had a great depth of knowledge in all areas on business visas in the US.

Satya Choudhury

20 September 2023

I had a great experience with Davies & Associates. They are very thorough in the approach and their have experts in this field who know the domain very well.I would certainly be leaning onto them for any future needs as well.

Hoshino Ryuichi

12 September 2023

Thanks to them for handling my E2 visa very professionally. I had a study visa from F1 and changed it to E2. I encountered many problems during the application process. Verdie and Etta were very patient in helping me and it took a long time. I highly recommend this place.

Picture of Us Immigration Lawyers
Us Immigration Lawyers
This is some biographical information.

Table of Contents

This article is published for clients, friends and other interested visitors for information purposes only. The contents of the article do not constitute legal advice and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Davies & Associates or any of its attorneys, staff or clients. External links are not an endorsement of the content.

Looking to acquire a U.S Visa?
To date, we have helped hundreds of families move to the United States and elsewhere, including the United Kingdom, Turkey, Grenada, Portugal and Italy.


We are known for our creative solutions that obtain "impossible" visas, we solve the most complex immigration problems for business, investors, individuals and families. Have a question or would like to discuss your visa requirements?